In Part 1, of our series on EEA applications we looked at the application process, and documents required to apply for an EEA family permit. Here, in the second part of our series, we look at EEA family permit refusals, focusing on the top 3 reasons for refusals and how to avoid them.
If you would like support with your EEA family permit application or a review of your draft application before submitting it, feel free to contact us at [email protected]
Background
EEA family permits are issued under the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2016 but has seen little change from Regulations 2006. The issue of the permits does not fall under UK Immigration Rules.
The purpose of the family permit is to allow overseas nationals, from outside of the European Economic Area (EEA), (or non-EEA nationals) to enter the United Kingdom (UK) and join their family member, as long as they are the:
- Family member of an EEA national, or
- Extended family member of an EEA national
There is no application fee and the process is not as onerous as compared to, say, applying for a UK spouse visa under the Immigration Rules. So what could possibly go wrong? Let’s explore…
Context
According to the Home Office’s National Immigration Statistics as of the end of 2018, the number of EEA family permits that were granted from 2015 to 2018 was as follows:
- 2015 – 30,302
- 2016 – 33,118
- 2017 – 27,106
- 2018 – 36,555
So, 30,302 EEA family permits were issued overseas in 2015. The number of EEA family permits issued rose by almost 10% in 2016 to 33,118. While there was a dip in the number of approvals in 2017, the numbers rose to their highest levels in 2018, a likely reflection of the high number of applications there were received in the run up to the UK’s departure from the European Union.
Extracting details of the number of successful applications and the rate of refusals is difficult and UK Visas and Immigration (UKVI), the body responsible for processing applications, is often unwilling to provide such specific data. Much of the data tends to include other types of applications and categories.
Yet, from direct experience, UKVI was well known for inappropriately refusing EEA family permits and using an inconsistent approach when considering applications.
When presenting cases in the immigration Tribunal on behalf of the Secretary of State, it was, unfortunately, not usual for applicants to successfully lodge an appeal against an adverse decision of an Entry Clearance Officer or in a few instances, to withdraw a UKVI decision because it was poorly argued.
Nowadays, the decision making has improved but the European Commission noted that non-EEA family members are still being denied family permits by UKVI on invalid grounds, or without a justified reason.
In fact, the European Commission stated:
Only in the UK is it possible to state that the number of refusals of entry or residence, as well as expulsions of EU citizens, is steadily on the rise
It went on to say:
National authorities indicate that this is the result of concerted efforts to refuse entry or to expel EU citizens convicted of a criminal offence, as well as EU citizens who do not meet the conditions attached to extended residence rights under Article 7 of the Directive. This indicates the UK’s willingness to publicly demonstrate that it is addressing popular concerns such as criminality and immigration, including the immigration of EU citizens
It’s hard to disagree with this. There are times when, the way in which non-EEA family members visa applications are handled appear to support the Commission’s assertions that barriers are deliberately being placed.
For instance, it is not uncommon for non-EEA family members to be asked to produce excessive levels of documentation so as to secure their permit and still experience delays of sometimes 12 weeks and beyond.
Similarly, it is difficult to assess the main reasons invoked by UKVI for refusing to grant non-EEA family members entry to the UK. Yet from past UKVI experience, research and information from clients looking for assistance after a refusal, the top 5 reasons for EEA family permits can be seen as follows…
Tops reasons for EEA family permit refusals
3. The applicant does not provide any (or adequate) evidence to support their claim to be the direct family member of an EEA national
Direct family members of EEA nationals are set out in Part 7 of the EEA Regulations as:
- Spouses or civil partners
- Direct descendants of the EEA national or their spouse/ civil partner under 21
- Dependent direct descendants of the EEA national or their spouse/ civil partner 21 and over
- Dependent direct relatives in the ascending line, for example parents and grandparents of the EEA national or their spouse / civil partner
The above members are viewed as the core of the EEA national’s family.
When assessing the application, it is important for documentary evidence is provided to UKVI to show the relationship between the non-EEA family member and the EEA national.
The type of documentary evidence needed will depend on the nature of the relationship. As a guide, such documents can include:
- An original marriage certificate supported by a certified translation, if appropriate
- An original civil partnership certificate supported by a certified translation, if appropriate
- A divorce certificate or a death certificate where there the EEA national or non-EEA national was previously married
- Original birth certificates naming the EEA national as one of the parents of the non-EEA child
- Original birth certificates naming the EEA national as the child of the non-EEA parent
2. The EEA national is not a qualified person because there is no evidence of Treaty rights being exercised
The purpose of the EEA family permit is to join or travel with the EEA national to the UK. To clarify, the EEA national must either:
- Be in the UK already
- Plan on travelling with you to the UK within 6 months of the date of your application
If the EEA national has been in the UK for more than 3 months they must either:
- Be a ‘qualified person’ who is exercising their ‘Treaty’ right by working, looking for work, self-employed, studying or self-sufficient); or
- Have a permanent right of residence in the UK
Where UKVI is not satisfied of the above, you can expect to receive an EEA family permit refusal with the following wording:
You have failed to provide evidence that your EEA national family member is a qualified person in accordance with Regulation 6 of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006. I am, therefore, not satisfied that your EEA national family member is residing in the UK in accordance with the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006.
To avoid this, it is important to evidence the EEA national’s permanent residence status, by way of an EEA permanent residence status, or show they are exercising their ‘Treaty rights’ by submitting original, stamped or certified documents appropriate to their circumstances – see our previous article for more details.
If the EEA national does not have a permanent residence status, some examples of recommended documents of exercising Treaty rights may include:
- Employment – an employment contract, payslips or a letter from an employer
- Self-employed – Service contracts, customer invoices or audited accounts with bank statements
- Studying – A letter from the UK school, college or university
- Financially self-sufficient – bank statements
EEA nationals that are financially self-sufficient or studying in the UK must have comprehensive medical insurance to be a ‘qualified person’ and it is recommended that evidence of insurance be submitted to UKVI.
1. The applicant is a party to a marriage of convenience
UKVI defines a marriage of convenience as an ‘abuse of the right to reside’. Unsurprisingly, where UKVI suspect that the marriage or civil partnership between the EEA national and non-EEA national was entered into to circumvent the UK immigration rules, the UKVI will issue a refusal with the following wording:
The definition of ‘spouse’ in the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006 does not include a party to a marriage of convenience. I am satisfied that you are party to a marriage of convenience and are therefore not the family member of an EEA national in accordance with Regulation 7 of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006.
One of my previous clients, a US national, was absolutely devastated to receive a letter from UKVI informing her that her recent marriage to a French national was a sham.
A similar sentiment was expressed by Mr Polyakov, a Russian national, married to his German wife, Anna who had sought an EEA family permit to visit his daughter and newly arrived grandson in the UK. Mr Polyakov was surprised to find that the genuineness of his marriage was doubted by UKVI because he had submitted his marriage certificate, but has not provided photographs of his wedding. Mr Polyakov and Mrs Polyakov have been married since 1975!
In the case of our client, she had followed the online guidance and submitted her original marriage certificate. UKVI’s guidance makes it clear that a valid marriage certificate is sufficient to prove a family relationship. In fact, where UKVI suspects that the marriage is one of inconvenience, the burden of proof falls on UKVI to support their assertion by testing their suspicions. This is supported by case law.
Yet despite this guidance, UKVI did not ask the client to provide additional information about the relationship. Nor had the client or her spouse been invited to an interview. Unfortunately, the client’s time frame for lodging an appeal had lapsed and so the decision to refuse the application for this reason could not be challenged.
She contacted Thomas Chase Immigration for the first time to assist her with a new application for an EEA family permit. By now, she had been married for 6 months.
To help the client increase her chances of success in securing an EEA family permit, she was advised to gather as many documents that she had that related to her relationship with her spouse. The purpose of this exercise was to show UKVI that despite the couple’s marriage of 6 months, the couple had been in a genuine relationship for over 2 years.
The following documents were submitted:
- Records of past communications between the couple such as Skype and WhatsApp messages
- Travel tickets of holidays taken together
- Photographs
We provided a covering letter, setting out the client’s circumstances, how she met the requirements, and touched on her previous refusal and how this application differed. We helped the client to make a strong application. Needless to say, the client’s application was approved.
Conclusion
EEA family permits can be refused for a number of reasons, many of which come as a total surprise to the applicant. By being aware of the pitfalls and preparing a strong application, the application process for an EEA family permit will likely go as smoothly as possible.
Have you or someone you know received a recent refusal? What were the reasons given and what advice would you give to others?
Share this blog with someone who might benefit from it.
This post was first published on 31 May 2017 and updated on 1 March 2019.
____________________________________________________________________
Written by Carla Thomas – Managing Director at Thomas Chase Immigration.
Thomas Chase Immigration offer immigration assistance to individuals, families and HR professionals.
Call to action
Need straightforward immigration advice or assistance with a visa application?
Contact us at [email protected] to arrange a consultation or to request assistance. You can also learn more about UK immigration from our blogs.
Liked this blog?
Drop us a line and let us know if you like this blog post. You might also like: